Progress and inequality | Business Standard
Progress and inequality | Business Standard
Online comments posted on October 18, 2013:
Online comments posted on October 18, 2013:
Dr Charan Singh has brought out
the focus of ‘The Great Escape’ in a self-contained essay which can perhaps
double up as an Executive Summary of Angus Deaton’s book. There will be many Indians
like me whose families would have escaped from poverty, thanks to parents’
foresight about education as a tool for survival.
The Indian experience is that
every geographical area with opportunities for education has come out of abject
poverty much faster. Kerala, Goa, Pudussery and Punjab are examples where
progress in human development indicators were more on account of improvement in
literacy than industrialisation. Looking from a different angle, industrialised
and urbanised states neglected education from a selfish interest to retain the
uniterrupted flow of cheap labour from rural to urban areas.
The observation “aid-generally
politically motivated and conditional-is not effective and is ‘likely to
perpetuate and prolong poverty and not eliminate it’, since fixing poverty is
not as easy as fixing a broken car” is very relevant in the present Indian
context. Much of our problems have origin in our neglect of the strength of
domestic institutions and resources and import of solutions which had lab tests
in totally uncomarable soil and circumstances.
Perhaps, The Great Escape read
with An Uncertain Glory by Sen and Dreze could change the approach of our
economists, donors and policy makers.
M G Warrier, Mumbai
Comments