When Rajan trashed the Economic Survey - Moneylife
When Rajan trashed the Economic Survey - Moneylife
The Economic Survey argued for RBI's reserves to be cut. The RBI governor came back with a stinging reply
Excerpts from Box 1.6 of Economic Survey 2016:
“….RBI is an outlier with an equity share of about 32%, second only to Norway and well above that of the US Federal Reserve Bank and the Bank of England, whose ratios are less than 2%. The conservative European Central Bank (ECB) and some EM central banks have much higher ratios, but even they do not approach the level of the RBI. If the RBI were to move even to the median of the sample (16%), this would free up a substantial amount of capital to be deployed for recapitalizing the PSBs. Of course, there are wider considerations that need to be taken into account…”
Use the link to read the full article*
M G Warrier
An excerpt from the report on the subject in the Financial Express, April 6, 2016 given below:
An excerpt from the report on the subject in the Financial Express, April 6, 2016 given below:
“Reserve
Bank of India (RBI) governor Raghuram Rajan on
Tuesday said that the suggestion in the Economic Survey for 2015-16 to the
effect that the central bank should use its capital and recapitalise
public sector banks (PSBs) was not a good one, reports fe Bureau in Mumbai.
“Whoever wrote that piece does not understand monetary policy economics or the
monetary balance sheet of banks,” the governor said, pointing out that the
RBI’s balance sheet was different from that of the banks.
Rajan clarified that he
did not intend to criticise the government but only the author of the report.
“The author of the piece
has not understood monetary economics that well and I would be happy to teach
them,” he quipped.
Rajan explained that, say,
the RBI monetises close to Rs 2 lakh crore, it could add Rs 2 lakh crore to the
size of the balance sheet. “However, if we give half of it to the government,
that means there is only Rs 1 lakh crore left to buy government bonds,” the
governor said, adding that the bonds will have to be sold in the market.
“So what we are saying is
given those constraints, any extra money we give to the government will
basically reduce our ability to buy government bonds directly,” Rajan said.
According to the Economic
Survey 2015-16, to address the economy’s critical short-term challenge of
public sector banks (PSBs) and some large corporates having highly stressed
balance sheets, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) could redeploy the capital at
its disposal for recapitalising the PSBs.
Noting that the RBI is an
outlier among the community of central banks with a high shareholder
equity-asset ratio of 32%, the survey’s authors recommended that without
compromising on its need to keep buffer capital to cope with eventualities like
perils to its forex reserves from the rupee’s volatility, the RBI could reallocate
a portion of its capital to the shareholder banks.
It had also said that the
RBI is next only to Norway’s central bank in holding a high portion of equity
(capital, retained earnings and contingencies) with itself — around Rs 8 lakh
crore now, including unrealised gains”.
M G Warrier
Comments